Green Options › Forums › Climate Change › Science › What the heck is going on with the Arctic sea ice this year?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

What the heck is going on with the Arctic sea ice this year?

post #1 of 40
Thread Starter 

The Arctic sea ice extent has been a roller coaster this year.

 

Normally it's pretty predictable - the ice begins to melt during the spring months, accelerates during the summer, slows toward the end of summer, begins recovering around October, then steadily increases in extent from November thru January.

 

This year there was a rapid acceleration in the melt during the summer.  At first it seemed as though the ice extent wouldn't decrease as much as in 2007, but after a big acceleration almost got there (and did break the record in terms of volume).  Then there was a fairly rapid recovery in October, and some of the deniers were predicting Arctic ice extent would return to 1979-2000 average levels (some even predicting it would recover to 1979 levels).

 

Well, as I predicted, Arctic sea ice didn't even come close to recovering to that level.  Not only that, but suddenly the recovery has essentially ceased, and suddenly the extent is below the 2007 record low.

 

Granted it's only maybe 2 weeks of flatlining, but it's extremely strange to see the Arctic sea ice recovery stop in December, of all months.

 

Anyone have any ideas what's going on?

post #2 of 40


blimey, what happened?!! i only looked last week, saw a little flat bit, but now its all going  wrong! and at  winter solstice, total darkness. it can only be the water temperature doing that. so this is the amplification they are on about, over and above the atmospheric warming.

 it makes you want to question the data, it looks so scarily wrong.

 

where do nsidc keep their previous years daily charts? i couldnt find them last time i looked. we dont actually know from comparing it to the average and to one other year how much it might wobble in general, last year might have been unusually steady.

 


Edited by gerda - Tue, 23 Dec 2008 17:26:01 GMT


Edited by gerda - Tue, 23 Dec 2008 17:27:58 GMT


no comment at nsidc yet i guess they are waiting to see what happens too.



Edited by gerda - Tue, 23 Dec 2008 17:32:35 GMT
post #3 of 40
Thread Starter 

Well I wouldn't jump to any conclusions just yet because it's still a short-term effect (just 1-2 weeks), but it is a very strange one.  Definitely something to keep an eye on.  I hadn't been, but pegminer pointed it out to me.

post #4 of 40

All that cold air blanketing the N. American continent came from the arctic.  Conservation of mass dictates air has to come from somewhere else to take its place.  The air coming in was warmer, keeping ice from forming.  Maybe.

 

post #5 of 40
Thread Starter 

Maybe.  We'll have to keep an eye on Arctic ice and North American temps over the next couple weeks.

post #6 of 40
Thread Starter 

Update - the Arctic sea ice extent has begun to expand again, pretty much right after I started this discussion.  So it's almost exactly in line with the 2007 (record low) levels at this point.  But at least it's no longer flatlining.

post #7 of 40

maybe there's a link with the recent cold weather across north america and china? we have had mild weather in uk for 3 weeks until 2 nights ago.

post #8 of 40

I'll be one of the first to point out the difference between weather and climate. But, I find this just a bit too disconcerting to simply brush it off when you look at its location in the high arctic of northern Greenland.  I know it's weather but are we looking a global warming extreme weather event?  Thoughts?

 

http://weather.noaa.gov/weather/current/BGTL.html

 

Latitude: 76° 31'

Longitude: 68° 45'

Current Weather Conditions:
Thule A. B., Greenland

(BGTL) 76-32N 068-45W 77M

Conditions at Jan 02, 2009 - 03:55 PM ESTJan 02, 2009 - 02:55 PM CSTJan 02, 2009 - 01:55 PM MSTJan 02, 2009 - 12:55 PM PSTJan 02, 2009 - 11:55 AM ASTJan 02, 2009 - 10:55 AM HST
2009.01.02 2055 UTC
Wind from the E (080 degrees) at 24 MPH (21 KT) gusting to 39 MPH (34 KT)
Visibility greater than 7 mile(s)
Sky conditions clear
Temperature 31.1 F (-0.5 C)
Windchill 17 F (-8 C)
Dew Point 20.3 F (-6.5 C)
Relative Humidity 63%
Pressure (altimeter) 29.9 in. Hg (1012 hPa)
Pressure tendency 0.04 inches (1.5 hPa) lower than three hours ago
ob BGTL 022055Z 08021G34KT 9999 CLR M01/M07 A2990 RMK AO2 PK WND 09038/2012 CIG 041 RWY26 SLP131 60000 T10051065 56015

Maximum and Minimum Temperatures

Maximum
Temperature
F (C)
Minimum
Temperature
F (C)
 
28.2 (-2.1) 27.1 (-2.7) In the 6 hours preceding Jan 02, 2009 - 12:55 PM EST / 2009.01.02 1755 UTC
34.2 (1.2) 20.7 (-6.3) In the 24 hours preceding Jan 01, 2009 - 10:55 PM EST / 2009.01.02 0355 UTC

Precipitation Accumulation

Precipitation
Amount
 
A trace In the 3 hours preceding Jan 02, 2009 - 03:55 PM EST / 2009.01.02 2055 UTC
0.41 inches In the 6 hours preceding Jan 02, 2009 - 12:55 PM EST / 2009.01.02 1755 UTC
1.22 inches In the 24 hours preceding Jan 02, 2009 - 06:55 AM EST / 2009.01.02 1155 UTC

24 Hour Summary

 
  Time
EST (UTC)
Temperature
F (C)
Dew Point
F (C)
Pressure
Inches (hPa)
Wind
MPH
Weather
Latest 4 PM (21) Jan 02 31.1 (-0.5) 20.3 (-6.5) 29.9 (1012) E 24  
  3 PM (20) Jan 02 30.0 (-1.1) 20.5 (-6.4) 29.9 (1012) E 31  
  2 PM (19) Jan 02 30 (-1) 21 (-6) 29.88 (1011) E 41 precipitation
  1 PM (18) Jan 02 28 (-2) 21 (-6) 29.93 (1013) E 33 precipitation
  Noon (17) Jan 02 28 (-2) 21 (-6) 29.94 (1013) E 38 precipitation
  11 AM (16) Jan 02 28 (-2) 21 (-6) 29.94 (1013) ESE 41 precipitation
  10 AM (15) Jan 02 28 (-2) 21 (-6) 29.92 (1013) ESE 44 light drizzle
  9 AM (14) Jan 02 26 (-3) 21 (-6) 29.91 (1012) E 48 light drizzle
  8 AM (13) Jan 02 28 (-2) 23 (-5) 29.96 (1014) ESE 38 haze
  7 AM (12) Jan 02 28 (-2) 23 (-5) 29.93 (1013) ESE 44 light drizzle
  6 AM (11) Jan 02 28 (-2) 23 (-5) 29.91 (1012) ESE 49 light drizzle
  5 AM (10) Jan 02 28 (-2) 23 (-5) 29.95 (1014) E 24 precipitation
  4 AM (9) Jan 02 28 (-2) 23 (-5) 29.93 (1013) ESE 37 precipitation
  3 AM (8) Jan 02 30 (-1) 23 (-5) 29.95 (1014) E 23 precipitation
  2 AM (7) Jan 02 30.6 (-0.8) 24.4 (-4.2) 29.94 (1013) E 15  
  1 AM (6) Jan 02 34.3 (1.3) 25.3 (-3.7) 29.96 (1014) Variable 6  
  Midnight (5) Jan 02 32.4 (0.2) 25.2 (-3.8) 29.97 (1014) E 14  
  11 PM (4) Jan 01 33.3 (0.7) 25.9 (-3.4) 29.98 (1015) ESE 29  
  10 PM (3) Jan 01 32.0 (0.0) 26.4 (-3.1) 29.98 (1015) E 22  
  9 PM (2) Jan 01 33.8 (1.0) 27.1 (-2.7) 29.98 (1015) SE 28  
  8 PM (1) Jan 01 32.4 (0.2) 26.6 (-3.0) 29.99 (1015) ESE 26  
  7 PM (0) Jan 01 31.8 (-0.1) 26.1 (-3.3) 30 (1015) ESE 24  
  6 PM (23) Jan 01 30.9 (-0.6) 26.2 (-3.2) 29.99 (1015) ESE 24 precipitation
Oldest 5 PM (22) Jan 01 30 (-1) 26 (-3) 29.99 (1015) ESE 23 precipitation
  Time
EST (UTC)
Temperature
F(C)
Dew Point
F(C)
Pressure
Inches(hPa)
Wind
(MPH)
Weather

 


 

I'm looking for a surface isothermic chart for this region for today. It would prove interesting but I doubt one exists.

 

Edited by gwens - Fri, 2 Jan 2009 21:48:46 UTC


Edited by gwens - Fri, 2 Jan 2009 21:58:48 UTC


Edited by gwens - Fri, 2 Jan 2009 22:13:03 UTC
post #9 of 40

isnt that a bit warm for the time of year? thule is well inside the actic circle innit?

 

edit; sorry gwens, you just said that, i skipped straight to the data. not knowing what the usual variation is, i shouldnt make a guess, but it does look very fishy. drizzle? in a place that holds the world record for wind speed?


Edited by gerda - Fri, 02 Jan 2009 22:21:51 GMT
post #10 of 40
Thread Starter 

Something to keep track of to see if that's just an anomaly.

 

Arctic sea ice extent has remained right on track with the 2007 record low, but the recovery has continued.

post #11 of 40

We get most of our cold weather from Arctic winds and it is frigid here and has been for the past month or so.  (-27c to -32c not including the windchill factor).  We are right on track with the Farmers Almanac and our climate has not been affected to date in Manitoba, Canada.  Weather patterns are another thing though as we have record amounts of snow already here.  Climate is what is expected and weather is what you get!

 

We are more than 25ppm Co2 over the danger line for Global Warming so I don't doubt that the seemingly unpredictable and strange weather and ice patterns are to do more with Global Warming than natural patterns or trends.

post #12 of 40
Thread Starter 

Holy cow.  If our temperatures got that low, I don't think I'd ever go outside!

post #13 of 40

I've been here all my life and I am still not used to it!  I live in a place they call "Winterpeg" (Winnipeg) and we have 2 seasons Winter and Construction.

 

It's difficult to convince skeptics here that Global Warming is real that's for sure!  The week before Christmas it dropped to -47c here with the windchill almost every day...it made for some interesting Christmas shopping especially since I refuse to ever idle or "warm up" the car for more than 60 seconds.

post #14 of 40

PUREShop I left Winnipeg last summer for the warmer climes of southern Ontario. It's now -4 C here.  Sorry but I was chucking to myself at your -31C this morning.

 

It's going to take considerable warming before Winnipeg notices any change in winter temps but there will be much more snow.

post #15 of 40

I also originate from Winterpeg but am now 115 km East of Winnipeg and enjoy the same weather but better scenery.  At least we have a dry cold. I found +4C with humidity in England worse than -30 C in Winnipeg. 

post #16 of 40
Quote:
Originally Posted by Whiteshell001:

I also originate from Winterpeg but am now 115 km East of Winnipeg and enjoy the same weather but better scenery.  At least we have a dry cold. I found +4C with humidity in England worse than -30 C in Winnipeg. 


Good to know....won't try moving to England to get away then!  Yes, we have definitely noticed more snow earlier this year.  I watched it fall all day long today.  The increase in snow could very well be our first taste at climate change.

 

Thanks Gwens....we have relatives who have also seeked refuge in Ontario and they also find our weather here chuckle worthy :)  I must say I still have trouble laughing at it!

post #17 of 40

Something we observe about Lake Huron ice cover, we will see ice cover reduce in its extent and consolidate around Grand Bend and Ipperwash. At that time the whole of the southern quarter of the lake is solidly covered, but the northern end may have large areas clear of ice, because the wind from the north has blown the ice to the south, and even piled it up 6 to 8 metres along the shore.

 

With the criteria being that area that has a given percentage cover, what was covered yesterday can be bare today with no reduction in ice. It can be a non-thermal event.

post #18 of 40

 

PUREShop, I'm not sure if you'll get this in time to see it but there is a gorgeous satellite composite showing the southerly flow into Manitoba giving you the snow.
 
I see the temperature in Thule is getting back to a cooler -20C.  I couldn't find much in the way of charts to see what was going on up there bringing such unusually warm weather to the area. 
A couple of years ago while doing a field school I had the chance to go to Alert Nunavut.  We had a fuel stop in Thule, and of course the old C-130 Hercules that was our transport, courtesy of the Canadian Air Force decided that's where it wanted to break down. We had three days to get to know Thule Air Base.  Between the Cold War relics, the Arctic foxes and the amazing local topography we found out  what an incredibly fascinating place it is. 
 To the east of the base in the 1950s the US government built two massive great earthen ramps to move equipment to the top of the ice cap, for whatever reason the DOD needed to be up there.  Other than the size of these ramps, over three hundred feet high, the most striking thing is the present distance that the top of the ramp is from the glacier today.  This picture, not mine I just found it on the internet, is of one of these ramps. In the background you can make out the top of the icecap and today the icecap is over a half mile away from where it originally met the ramp a little over fifty years ago.  Standing on the top of that ramp is what really drove home to me the fact that the climate was changing.
 
post #19 of 40
Quote:
Originally Posted by dana1981:

Holy cow.  If our temperatures got that low, I don't think I'd ever go outside!


 

Well now Dana I do believe I see palm trees in the background of your photo.

post #20 of 40
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gwens:

 

Well now Dana I do believe I see palm trees in the background of your photo.

 

Haha not palms, but regular trees like oaks and ashes and such.  Palm trees are more of a southern California thing.

 

It rarely gets below 0 deg C around here though.  That's more than cold enough for me!

post #21 of 40

gosh thanks canadians all, thats made me feel much better about our paltry week at -2C!

(but yes whiteshell, a damp cold, gets into your bones).

post #22 of 40

Just when you think it can't get any worse, this came up on the internet.

 

Record cold wind chills of -50 C recorded overnight in Saskatchewan

2 hours, 23 minutes ago

 

By Jim Macdonald, The Canadian Press--

 

UNDATED - A fierce blast of snow and cold was making its way east into Manitoba on Sunday after triggering record low wind chills of -50 C and colder in neighbouring Saskatchewan overnight.

 

Wind chill warnings were in effect in both provinces throughout the day, prompting warnings from Environment Canada that exposed skin would freeze in less than 10 minutes.

 

Residents of Saskatoon woke up to the coldest temperatures since 1966, with a wind chill of -45 C, leaving the city shrouded in ice fog.

 

Regina and other areas of southern Saskatchewan were still digging out from up to 25 centimetres of snow that began Friday.

 

In Moose Jaw, 3,000 homeowners were without power for up to four hours Saturday as the result of a major house fire that left firefighters covered in ice.

 

Manitobans woke up Sunday shivering in wind chills of -45 C in Brandon and Dauphin and flights were delayed out of Winnipeg as the city digs out from nearly 15 centimetres of snow.

 

A pregnant woman and her two toddlers were among seven people taken to hospital following a three-vehicle collision Saturday on Highway 6 north of Winnipeg that police blamed on poor road conditions.

 

Southeastern Manitoba was buried in up to 20 centimetres of snow Saturday.

 

Drivers across the region were being warned Sunday about blowing and drifting snow and travel was not recommended on Highway 44 west from the Ontario boundary.

 

Some flights at the Winnipeg airport were delayed up to five hours Saturday when the landing gear failed on a small plane at the intersection of two runways.

 

No planes could land or depart until the aircraft was towed by its owner roughly three hours after it become stranded.

 

Although temperatures were easing slightly in Alberta, the cold weather still managed to find victims.

 

A 45-year-old man trying to dash over a fence near downtown Calgary injured his leg and got caught on the fence. Police say the man was suffering from hypothermia by the time he was rescued.

 

Milder weather was expected to begin moderating temperatures in Alberta and parts of Saskatchewan Sunday, with temperatures warning to -12 C Monday in Saskatoon.

 

Meanwhile, the legacy of a fierce blizzard that hammered Atlantic Canada on New Year's Eve turned tragic Sunday as searchers found the body of a man from Prince Edward Island who vanished on his way home from the night's festivities.

 

Kyle Alvin Bambrick, 18, was last seen around three a.m. on Jan. 1 when he headed out into a severe snowstorm in the rural community of Clyde River, west of Charlottetown.

 

http://ca.news.yahoo.com/s/capress/090104/national/prairie_cold_snap?printer=1


Edited by gwens - Sun, 4 Jan 2009 22:01:37 UTC
post #23 of 40

well, its our second week of - temps here, while the scientists at rothera are in their shorts basking in a balmy +5C chiz.

post #24 of 40
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gwens:

Just when you think it can't get any worse, this came up on the internet.

 

Record cold wind chills of -50 C recorded overnight in Saskatchewan

 

Oh my word!  I honestly cannot even imagine temperatures that cold.  It's so funny...I'm in the San Francisco Bay Area and it's been cold for around here...with lows in the 40's F or 8 C.

 

No wonder one of the NHL announcers couldn't leave Saskatchewan the other day!

post #25 of 40

the yearly review is in.

 

"December's week-long pause in expansion of the ice cover appears to have been caused, at least in part, by an anomalous atmospheric pressure pattern. High pressure over Alaska and the European Arctic, coupled with unusually low pressure east of Greenland and over eastern Siberia, brought warm southerly winds over much of the Arctic Ocean. The southerly winds helped keep the ice edge from expanding southward. In addition, warm sea surface temperatures, at least in the Barents Sea, inhibited ice formation."

 

 

post #26 of 40
Thread Starter 

Aha well that answers my question.  Thanks gerda.

post #27 of 40

...i'm a sea ice cheerleader.....how sad....

 

 

so gcnp had the answer. north america got the arctic weather for a fortnight.


Edited by gerda - Fri, 09 Jan 2009 19:12:57 GMT
post #28 of 40
Quote:
Originally Posted by gerda:

...i'm a sea ice cheerleader.....how sad....

 

 

so gcnp had the answer. north america got the arctic weather for a fortnight.


Edited by gerda - Fri, 09 Jan 2009 19:12:57 GMT

 

Believe in three things:  the Copernican principle, the principle of parsimony, and on classical scales, conservation of mass/momentum. 

 

If arctic air moves south, warmer air from somewhere else has to replace it. 

post #29 of 40

looks like it happened again. sea ice growth stalled while we had blizzards.

 

january roundup just in.

 

"As is typical during mid-winter, sea ice extent increased overall in January; maximum monthly extent is expected in March. However, January ice extent remained well below normal compared to the long-term record. Ice extent averaged for January 2009 is the sixth lowest January in the satellite record. Also of note is that from January 15 to 26, ice extent saw essentially no increase; an unusual wind pattern appears to have been the cause."

 

post #30 of 40

Back on topic: Sunday's L.A. Times has a front page article titled, "Under ice, a threat bubbles: Methane pockets locked in the Arctic could change Earth's climate."

 

The reporter is Margot Roosevelt, reporting from the Bering Land Bridge National Preserve.  It's not a bad piece, and should serve to educate a lot of people.

New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Science
Green Options › Forums › Climate Change › Science › What the heck is going on with the Arctic sea ice this year?