Green Options › Forums › Sustainable Living Discussions › Personal Care & Clothing › Medical journal The Lancet Tuesday withdrew a 1998 study linking autism with inoculation
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Medical journal The Lancet Tuesday withdrew a 1998 study linking autism with inoculation

post #1 of 7
Thread Starter 
From Yahoo news: http://news.yahoo.com/s/afp/20100202/wl_uk_afp/healthdiseasevaccinationautism

The Medical Journal - The Lancet Tuesday withdrew a 1998 study linking autism with inoculation against three childhood illnesses, a paper that caused an uproar and an enduring backlash against vaccination.

"We fully retract this paper from the published record," The Lancet's editors said in a statement published online. 

My comment - İt is still going to take years more to get past this guys foolishness unfortunately. Many more kids will be exposed and some sickened without good reason!
post #2 of 7
I agree, Russ.  There are already so many nails in the coffin of the supposed link between vaccinations and autism, this is just another one.  The myth will persist, though.
post #3 of 7
I was just writing about vaccines over at a pregnancy blog I write for - this is a weird coincidence. I'm a vaccine supporter for my own son, but mainly because for me, it's the lesser of two evils. Working in health care I saw some really bad side effects of vaccines, and many of my friends don't believe in them (because of the autism deal or other fears about them not being well tested enough). However, as a parent I have enough to worry about - drowning, broken legs, bike helmets, and all that other safety stuff. I got my son vaccinated because major illnesses are one less worry for me.

I don't think vaccines are totally safe though - it's rare that anything in medicine is 100% safe and I think it should be a parent's choice. There's been a lot of talk about forcing vaccines or making them a legal issue but I think that would open a door we maybe don't want opened. It would make me wonder where it would all end - like would home births and homeschooling be more open to bans, etc.

That's a great link though Russ, I'll have to post it over at the pregnancy/baby blog.

Oh, and here's more info for those who show up here and want it: Vaccine safety websites that meet WHO credibility and content good information practices criteria.
post #4 of 7
Thread Starter 
Hi Jennifer, You as a nurse know better than others that nothing in medicine is guaranteed. İ personally think that in a few hundred years they will look back and wonder how we ever survived. 

My children were vaccinated. My daughter is a nurse and our granddaughter is vaccinated. İ would prefer to see it be mandatory as it is a public health issue - it can not affect one person only.

İ also believe that home schooling is not a good thing - to many badly adjusted kids out there already. A kid needs to learn to interact with others from the first in preparation for the rest of it's life.   
post #5 of 7
I unschooled Cedar for most of his life, and now he attends a Free school. I'm not on board with public schooling at all. I'm not on board with lazy homeschoolers either, because they make all home/unschoolers look bad. BUT there's no way I'd send Cedar to public school.

The social interaction issues surrounding homeschooling are for the most part total myth in my opinion. Most of the unschoolers and homeschoolers I know hang out with all sorts of people all the time. Schools produce plenty of socially damaged kids or kids who think they need to be like everyone else.

I'd rather Cedar learn early on that all ages and types of folks interact vs. him thinking he should only be interacting with peers who are his exact age. I'd also rather he know that learning can happen 24/7 vs. from 9-3 M-F and that learning can be self-motivated vs. you can only learn on some weird arbitrary schedule (i.e. cursive at age nine, multiplication at age 7, and so on) - that's a false way to learn. People don't become invested in learning when forced. It's sort of like green living - you can't force it.

One day we'll agree on something... maybe not soon granted... 
post #6 of 7
PS while I don't agree that vaccines should be forced I do think parents should think about the future ramifications of not vaccinating. For example, your child's possible future pregnancies. Some illnesses can cause serious complications for unborn babies and the best time to get vaccinated is BEFORE you conceive. Many vaccines are not considered safe during pregnancy but when given before conception, these vaccines can help ensure a healthy pregnancy. Important vaccines include rubella immunization and the varicella vaccine. If someone is pregnant and not vaccinated against these two illness then get said illnesses while pregnant it can cause a host of health problems for the baby. That's one major reason I believe in vaccines as a good option.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Russ View Post


My children were vaccinated. My daughter is a nurse and our granddaughter is vaccinated. İ would prefer to see it be mandatory as it is a public health issue - it can not affect one person only.
 
post #7 of 7
Thread Starter 
You give the public more credit than İ am able to. İ believe that given the opportunity most people will find a way to mess things up most of the time - people have managed to do so for a few thousand years so why change now?

Same with home schooling - can it be done well? Certainly! Can it be done very well? Certainly! Are public schools the best they can be? No! (very far from it). Public schooling will always be designed for the bottom third of the class - not for the capable kids. 

Home schooling is only as good as the parents are and here İ revert back to the first sentence. There are the 'hiding from the world' types that bother me most. Some that scare me are religious and some not.
 
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Personal Care & Clothing
Green Options › Forums › Sustainable Living Discussions › Personal Care & Clothing › Medical journal The Lancet Tuesday withdrew a 1998 study linking autism with inoculation