Green Options › Forums › Sustainable Living Discussions › Babies & Kids › American Red Cross says please do not send breast milk donations to Haiti!
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

American Red Cross says please do not send breast milk donations to Haiti!

post #1 of 5
Thread Starter 
I'm sure some of you have seen all the posts about breast milk needed in Haiti, and while this is not totally a green topic, it's an important topic so I thought I'd post what's new.

Spokesman for the American Red Cross, Eric Porterfield, says, don't send any breast milk, "I’m 100 percent sure we didn’t ask for that." According to reports, "The international Emergency Nutrition Network has asked one group, the Human Milk Banking Association of North America, to retract a press release this week that issued an “urgent call” for breast milk for orphaned and premature infants in Haiti, saying the donations contradict best practices for babies in emergencies."

I agree that we should not send breast milk. Women can and should breastfeed during a crisis which came up during World Breastfeeding Week 2009 when the World Alliance for Breastfeeding Action (WABA), and breastfeeding advocates sought to dispel common misconceptions and myths surrounding breastfeeding during emergencies, because crisis or not, breastfeeding is best. The WABA notes that when emergency relief teams come in with formula and bottles babies suffer and it's also not as healthy for mamas.


Breast milk donations also result in problems related to transportation, screening, supply and storage and create an “unfeasible and unsafe intervention,” according to a statement from the Office of U.S. Foreign Disaster Assistance, or OFDA.


If you'd like to help Haiti you can send money donations which will be better used. Learn more about why breast milk is not a useful donation at this time.
 

*Source

post #2 of 5
Anything fresh in a disaster zone is at a very great premium - if breast milk is not classified as fresh then İ suppose nothing can be.

That anyone could consider adding to the load of those trying to save lives there during the month after the disaster shows me a major disconnect with reality. 
post #3 of 5
Thread Starter 
There's still controversy over this too - many people still want to send milk. Here in the U.S. you can donate breast milk to women who need it here. In 2005 alone the HMBANA milk banks sent milk to hospitals in over 80 cities located in 29 states and 3 Canadian provinces. This milk is important right here where we live.

I like that people are nice enough to think of others and try to help, but it's smartest, in my opinion to help those closest to you first - build community from the inside out. It always astounds me when people send funds to other countries to feed kids or do whatever but often aren't doing anything to help their own neighbors.
post #4 of 5
Hi Jennifer - just as you note, if a lady would would like to donate it can be done domestically where it is helpful and not creating problems.

While breast milk is first choice İ am sure that in Haiti that not much is first choice these days - not even tenth choice. Trying to organize feeding all that need a small amount of anything is a real difficult task. Salad is not an many Haitians menu this week and that is less perishable than breast milk.

The international response for a special event allows people to donate something and tell themselves how good they are. İf they do the same domestically then they have to realize they really have little reason not to do the same daily or at least more often so they can't get the 'good person' high.

İ thought the story about the missionary bunch that got thrown in for taking kids across the border to Santa Domingo without documents was a bit strange. They were so busy telling themselves how wonderful they are doing glorious work they forgot to take care of necessary steps. Now someone from the state department will have to spend time to get the fools out of trouble. Rather than being helpful they just made a bigger mess.  
post #5 of 5
The military has been having great fun with the NGO's of the world - all showing up at their own convenience and demanding they be treated as first in line because they are such wonderful people.

Even a French government air shipment got into the same squabble. With very limited landing and off loading capacity İ expect the planes landing and turnaround times were scheduled before they ever left the ground so when someone tries to muscle their way into line it is not so good.

The many in the NGO bunch have learned quite well that semi truths, half truths and outright lies are often the easiest way to get what they want and in their opinions what they want is of prime importance - to hell with everyone else. 
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Babies & Kids
Green Options › Forums › Sustainable Living Discussions › Babies & Kids › American Red Cross says please do not send breast milk donations to Haiti!