Overall I think the Yes To Carrots Nourishing Shampoo is a great product. It doesn't have an overpowering smell. It leaves my hair feeling clean and soft, never with any weird residue, and it does suds up in the traditional shampoo way. Value wise, it's great because I can pick it up from my local Walgreens for maybe $8, compared to some of the other "high end" organic shampoos I've looked at in Whole Foods. I would definitely buy this one again and would recommend it for anyone looking for a regular shampoo with an eco-bent.