I like this Pangea toner a lot. It smells great, it's made from natural ingredients, the glass bottle is recyclable, and the packaging is "plantable" (meaning it has seeds embedded into the box so you can bury it and have it grow). My skin isn't very oily but sometimes you need something to just feel fresh under your lotion. I would choose this over any conventional toner as it's not harsh. If you're really in the market for an intense astringent, this might not be for you. But for something gentler that's not drying, I highly recommend this product.