Pros: non-toxic, softens clothes, less packaging
Cons: didn't remove strong smells and tough stains
This is quite an interesting detergent and impressive I might add. First I was impressed by the list of ingredients. It's the first time I see all the ingredients of a laundry product listed in such a prominent way on the package. Not only that, I see nothing scary in it and I applaud. The second thing that I found rather pleasing was the individually packed dosages. They are very convenient, especially for people that have to go to the laundromat or the basement, or anywhere outside their dwellings, to do laundry. This way you don't have to carry a whole box with you. You can just toss the little packet in with the clothes and stick everything in the machine. Another advantage for me is that I don't have to measure the detergent, not because I am lazy, but because I am always worried that I probably used too much.
Performance wise, I would have to say that this detergent did not do better than other ones I have used. I would say it did just as well with your regular dirt but not so well with persistent stains. Oily stains and blood stains did not go away and unfortunately the smells didn't either. Clothes that were moderately dirty like sheets and towels came out great, smelling fresh. But my husband's stinky work clothes, or my cloth pads, not so much. Next time, I will use some laundry booster to help things along, which I always do, I just wanted to test this without them. What I do love however, is that the clothes come out softer than with other detergents and require less ironing.
Overall, I think this is a great idea. Less packaging, truly green ingredients (as far as I know) convenience for people who have no washing machine and have to go far to do laundry. However, I find it a bit expensive something that makes it prohibitive for large families that have to do more laundry than some of us.